Scrum vs SAFe: Key Differences & Top Interview Questions to Crack the Job
Scrum vs SAFe: Key Differences & Top Interview Questions to Crack the Job
Whether you are a developer, a project manager, or an aspiring Scrum Master, you’ve likely bumped into the Great Agile Debate: Scrum vs. SAFe.
Think of it like choosing between a nimble speedboat and a massive cruise ship. Both get you across the ocean, but the experience, the crew, and the steering are worlds apart. If you’re preparing for a job interview, understanding these nuances isn’t just "good to know"—it’s the difference between sounding like a textbook and sounding like an expert.
1. The Core Philosophy: Small Scale vs. Giant Scale
What is Scrum?
Scrum is the "OG" of Agile. It’s a lightweight framework designed for a single team (usually 5–9 people). It’s built on transparency, inspection, and adaptation. In Scrum, you work in short bursts called Sprints (usually 2 weeks) to deliver a "Done" increment of a product.
What is SAFe (Scaled Agile Framework)?
SAFe is what happens when a massive corporation (think 500+ developers) wants to be Agile. It takes the principles of Scrum and scales them up to the "Enterprise" level. SAFe synchronizes alignment, collaboration, and delivery across a large number of teams.
|
Scrum |
SAFe |
|
|---|---|---|
|
Team Size |
1 Team (5–11 people) |
Multiple Teams (50–125+ people) |
|
Roles |
SM, PO, Developers |
Scrum roles + RTE, STE, Product Mgmt |
|
Planning |
Sprint Planning (Every 2 weeks) |
PI Planning (Every 8–12 weeks) |
|
Coordination |
Daily Scrum |
Scrum of Scrums / ART Sync |
|
Complexity |
Low (Team-centric) |
High (Portfolio/Value Stream-centric) |
3. The "Big Brother" Concepts in SAFe
If you're in a SAFe environment, you'll hear terms that don't exist in basic Scrum. You need to know these for your interview:
- The ART (Agile Release Train): This is a long-lived team of Agile teams. It’s the "vehicle" that delivers value in SAFe.
- PI Planning (Program Increment): This is the heartbeat of SAFe. Every 8–12 weeks, the entire "Train" meets (often for two full days) to plan the next increment, map dependencies, and identify risks.
- The RTE (Release Train Engineer): Think of this person as the "Chief Scrum Master." They facilitate the ART and keep the train on the tracks.
4. Pros and Cons: Which one wins?
Scrum: The Freedom Fighter
- Pros: Minimal overhead, fast decision-making, high autonomy for the team.
- Cons: Can struggle when 20 teams need to work on the same product; dependencies can become a nightmare.
SAFe: The Organized Giant
- Pros: Provides a clear roadmap for big companies; handles dependencies across teams beautifully; aligns the "C-suite" with the developers.
- Cons: Can feel bureaucratic; "Top-down" planning can sometimes stifle the very agility it tries to create.
5. Interview Prep: Cracking the "Agile" Question
During a job interview, you might get asked: "Which framework is better?"
The Trap: Picking one and trashing the other.
The Pro Answer: "It depends on the context. Scrum is fantastic for team-level execution and rapid experimentation. However, if we are working in a complex environment with 200 developers where architectural runway and cross-team dependencies are the biggest risks, SAFe provides the structure needed to ensure we aren't all pulling in different directions."
Common Interview Questions:
- "How does Scrum exist within SAFe?"
- Answer: SAFe actually uses Scrum at the team level! Each team in the Agile Release Train (ART) operates using Scrum (or Kanban) for their daily work.
- "What is the biggest challenge of SAFe?"
- Answer: Managing the shift from "Command and Control" to "Lean-Agile Leadership." It’s easy to do the ceremonies, but hard to change the culture.
- "How do you handle dependencies in Scrum vs. SAFe?"
- Answer: In Scrum, you handle them via informal communication or a "Scrum of Scrums." In SAFe, you use the Program Board during PI Planning to visually map dependencies between teams.
Comments
Post a Comment